Because of the inherent change in the position of the center of mass of the bar between the front and back squat lifts, the back squat results in decreased back extensor muscle activity erector spinae 1. By combining the two most commonly used variations the front squat and the back squat this workout will push all of these muscle groups to the max. It is a fantastic exercise, but not all squats are created equal the most popular squat exercise is the barbell back squat, in which a weighted bar is balanced on the shoulders behind the neck. Pdf a biomechanical comparison of back and front squats in. What are the benefits of front squats over back squats. The difference between a front and back squat, beyond the bar. It targets more the quads and needs more core stabilization. Aug 08, 2015 front squats more difficult that back squats and why 20150808 ti health and fitness athletic performance, back squat, barbell, crossfit, exercise, front squat, sport 1 comment when it comes to the side by side comparison of athletic training and exercises, the front squat has greater demand vs. Pdf biomechanics of front and back squat exercises researchgate. Try these 8 mobility exercises and stretches to enhance your mobility and performance in the clean and front squat. When comparing the back and front squat in this experiment it all comes down to barbell placement.
Back squat exercise demonstration video and information for olympic weightlifting aka squat the back squat is the most basic strength exercise in weightlifting, and one of the most commonly used exercises other than the competition lifts. You need excellent thoracic spine upper back mobility to keep your chest up, outstanding wrist flexibility and shoulder mobility to rack the bar, superb hip and groin mobility to front squat low with your knees in line with your toes, and fantastic ankle mobility to keep your lower back from rounding. In relation to the maximum compression forces, are better in back squat, and shear forces are slightly better in front squat, at lumbar level. Traditionally, when you think of someone squatting with a bar, its usually a back squat. Back squats also create greater compressive downward forces at the knees. This means that the range of motion in the hips is generally longer for the back squat. In the knee, the total energy in front squat is greater than back squat in a 7. Although ive personally helped plenty of people with chronically bad backs learn to squat painfree in a matter of months if not weeks, those with a history of lower back issues should probably refrain from back squatting, at least temporarily. Finally, if you want to target the quads specifically, the back squat spreads the load to your entire leg area and will only be hampered by a weak point such as weak glutes or hamstrings. Seen as the younger brother to the back squat, the front squat is an often forgotten or neglected exercise with a host of benefits. A combination of mobility and motor control issues can impact an athletes ability to maintain a neutral spine while squatting. Effects of barbell back squat stance width on sagittal and frontal hip. The position of the bar forces the torso to remain more upright in a front squat than a back squat.
Why the smith machine is better than barbells for the. Elite weightlifters who front squat only and why you shouldn. I finally got a chance to read over rippetoes book, starting strength. The rest of the technique was the same as the back squat. So, for ac joint pain suffers, the back squat is a safer bet. May 09, 2016 for the sake of this comparison i am going to be using the high bar version of the back squat. The front squat mimics the same movement from the catch and when trained without a belt at higher speeds, the front squat is the clear victor in improving the clean. Front squats target this muscle a bit better than back squats. A solid air squat provides the foundation for variations including the back squat, front squat and overhead squat. Compared to the front squat version, back squat exhibited significantly greater trunk lean, with no differences occurring in the knee joint kinematics throughout the movement. The results suggest that front squats may be advantageous compared with back squats for individuals with knee problems such as meniscus tears, and for longterm joint health. The squat sounds like a great exercise to be doing, right.
Front squat v back squat northeastern strength and. Squats have been one of the most popular, and when done correctly, most beneficial movement in any training facility you go in. Front squat is the shit especially if you got some long ass femur. However, a back squat performed with a tight core and good technique is just as safe and effective. In terms of variations, there are numerous ways to load up a typical squat including a barbell on the back, in front, or overhead. D in sport studies, we always did olympicstyle back squats. However, saladino scoffs at this notion, arguing that its nothing more than nonsense used to help trainers market programs. The book mentions that the front squat is a totally different lift, but doesnt really say anything about it. Oct 11, 2012 video originally uploaded march 25, 2012 this video talks about the differences between front and back squats.
So if your best back squat is 315 pounds, your front squat ought to be around 280. Two of the most common lifts are the back squat and the front squat. Depending on which variation you choose, no other exercise challenges the quads, glutes, lower back, abs, upper back and shoulders quite the way squats do. Move this bar to the upper back, and the pain is avoided altogether. After that, the load will be based on your front squat strength. Front squat vs back squat one holds barbell in a different position in these two squat positions with the barbell on front shoulders in front squat and on the upper back in back squat. The quadriceps, hamstrings, gluteus muscles, erector spinae, gastrocnemius, soleus, adductor and abdominal muscles all are trained with this one exercise. Is the single leg squat better than the back squat. The reason is as you stated, the upper back is the limiting factor in the strengthperformance of a front squat. A comparison of gluteus maximus, biceps femoris, and vastus. So yes, i would take the single leg squat over the barbell squat anyday.
Of course if you dont want to giveup the back squat then by all means dont. The front squat will transfer quite well to the catch position of the clean, much more so than the back squat. Elite weightlifters who front squat only and why you. Im not trying to say the back squat is a bad exercise. It has been observed that back squat has a great impact on spine and doing back squats makes ones spine strong. The squat can both greatly improve your athleticism and keep your hips, back, and knees sound and functioning in your senior years. Even though quads are a little more recruited during a front squat than on. The front squat is more difficult than the back squat also because it involves a less stable position, where the barbell is placed in front resting on your shoulders, and this will prevent you from lifting as heavy compared to back squats. Yes, youll be forced to go a little lighter on your back squats afterwards, but the long term benefits in quad strength and size make it worthwhile.
Front squats also teach you to push your knees out to prevent valgus knee collapse kneeknock. Some coaches believe that a lifter should be able to front squat 90% of the weight that heshe back squats. Front squats more difficult that back squats and why 20150808 ti health and fitness athletic performance, back squat, barbell, crossfit, exercise, front squat, sport 1 comment when it comes to the side by side comparison of athletic training and exercises, the front squat has greater demand vs. For olympic lifting, we do them because it improve the clean. It is a fantastic exercise, but not all squats are created equal. For some, front squats may be the more uncomfortable squat of the two, whereas others will hate the positioning of the zercher squat.
Front squats requires significantly more mobility than back squats. As there are many variations of the squat, for the purpose of this article, the focus will be on front squats vs. On the surface, front squats are safer than the back squat due to less excessive forward leaning. Its popular, its what powerlifters compete with, and youre going to be able to back squat much more weight than a front squat. View the table of contents for this issue, or go to the journal homepage for more. In general, you cannot front squat as much as you can back squat about 85% of your back squat.
A biomechanical comparison of back and front squats in. The jefferson squat differs from the back squat in that the movement is often an assistance lift done to isolate a specific muscle group quads and glutes, rather than being a standalone. Save your back by switching to front squats breaking muscle. The front squat and back squat are two of the primary lower body dominant strength and power exercises that almost every strength program contains. Im also guilty of being a more hip dominant back squatter when in my most comfortable setup which caused my quads to not get as strong as i would like. The front squat placed the most amount of torque on the knee joint 220.
Additionally from the major difference in the two squatting techniques front squat vs back squat. For the sake of this comparison i am going to be using the high bar version of the back squat. However, i dont see the benefit for bodybuilding purpose. However, this does not mean back squatting is more dangerous to the lumbar spine. In the back squat, the barbell is behind the neck, across the trapezius. You need excellent thoracic spine upper back mobility to keep your chest up, outstanding wrist flexibility and shoulder mobility to rack the bar, superb hip and groin mobility to squat low with your knees in line with your toes. You should use both back squats and front squats in your training.
Sometimes i still back squat just for the funi had some fucking sacroiliac joint issue for years, full rom front squat with perfect form cured it. And i have to tell you i learned a ton on the back squat, which will really help me in the gym. Front squat to back squat ratio olympic lifting forums. The first thing to point out is that any given athlete is capable of lifting more weight in a back squat than in a front squat. A big knee stabilizing muscle is the vastus medialis oblique your inner quadriceps. The back squat is a fine exercise that allows you to lift a lot of weight, but unless you have short legs and long torso, you may need to add leg presses andor front squats to acquire a balanced lower body development. For actual muscle engagement the bar position doesnt matter. The angle of the hip for back squat is greater than the other variant. The low back remains in a neutral position during the entire squat.
In many cases, it starts when people hear about elite weightlifters who front squat only no back squats. In the front squat the barbell is in front of the neck, across the front of the shoulders. Difference between front and back squat compare the. Front squats place the bar on the front of the deltoids, placing the elbows and wrists at.
Front squats more difficult that back squats and why ti. Make your choice based on comfort at this point, youve probably decided whether or not youd rather do front squats or zercher squats. The most popular squat exercise is the barbell back squat, in which a weighted bar is balanced on the shoulders behind the neck. If adequate mobility is present in all necessary joints but movement quality is below standards, motorcontrol imbalances are to blame. The difference between a front and back squat, beyond the. Outside of a specific context, there isnt a clear winner. This is the one we all learned back in high school gym class and the one every powerlifter. Results may suggest that the front squat may be preferred to the back squat for knee extensor development and for preventing possible lumbar injuries during maximum loading.
This indicates a greater compromise at low back due to the possible lumbar shear forces. It was 1977, and i had just been in a little altercation that convinced me that i might need to be in a little better shape than i was. The mean values for the knee and ankle joints are similar for both variants of the exercise. Not only is the squat not detrimental to the knees it is remarkably rehabilitative of cranky, damaged, or delicate knees. Kinematic and emg activities during front and back squat. Execution place the barbell behind your neckretract your shoulder blades tightly and rest the bar in the me. The back squat is the single greatest massbuilding exercise, and it is a fullbody compound movement. Im assuming that the torso posture is the same, except you squat between your. Since all of the weight sits in front of you, the actual squatting movement changes quite a bit, too. If youre training to build raw strength and power, this is the squat you want to do, for a variety of reasons. Dec 23, 2014 the front squat and the back squat are two brothers.
Following your normal warmup, do one set of 1215 reps of front squats with just the bar. If the squat is king of all exercises, then consider the front and back squat the four legs it sits upon. Low back strengthening can be accomplished by using proper squatting form, regardless of whether youre doing a back or front squat. Typically people who are good at both squats will be able to front squat 7580% of their max back squat. First off, you can place more weight on the bar when you back squat than you can with the front squat, and when youre chasing pure power and strength, you need to move as much weight as you can. When i was throwing shot and discus years ago under two different national coaches one of whom was a former canadian champ with many years of experience and the other was a former polish national coach who had a ph. The squat comes with a slew of variations and techniques that cater to all athletes from the powerlifting, weightlifting and crossfit community. Front squats more difficult that back squats and why. The general setup position for an air squat as demonstrated by crossfit inc. Front squat vs back squat powerlifting forums t nation. The front squat was as effective as the back squat in terms of overall muscle recruitment, with significantly less compressive forces and extensor moments. Starting strength the squat, or how i learned to stop legpressing and use my ass by mark rippetoe 1 i learned to squat a long time ago. Biomechanics of front and back squat exercises iopscience.
That fact, combined with the fact that more weight can be used, makes most analysts consider the back squat to be a core basic movement and the front squat to. Lets talk about front squats and back squats, and i can share with you briefly how i use these exercises to my benefit. Hey guys, what is your back squat to front squat ratio. Video originally uploaded march 25, 2012 this video talks about the differences between front and back squats. Apr 20, 2016 the front squat placed the most amount of torque on the knee joint 220. My personal thoughts on the issue of front squats vs. Biomechanics of front and back squat exercises article pdf available in journal of physics conference series 901. The barbell back squat is a widely popular and utilized. Back squatting isnt for everyone, but lets not throw the baby out with the bathwater. By pulling the body forward and increasing knee flexion as a lifter descends into a squat, front squats place more emphasis on the quads rather than the glutes.
Back squats low bar or high bar place the bar on the upper back or trapezius. Pdf squat constitutes one of the most popular exercises to. This means the front squat placed roughly 15% more torque on the knees than the highbar squat and 57% more than the lowbar squat. Front squats place the bar on the front of the deltoids, placing the elbows and wrists at full extension.
Many strength and conditioning coaches will tell you that the back squat is the end all be all exercise. There tends to be an ongoing debate between which style of squat is better. This is the one we all learned back in high school gym class and the one every powerlifter likes to brag about. In contrast to back squats, which place the barbell on the upper back, front squats challenge the body by placing the barbell in front, resting on the shoulders. Meaning you will get stronger, faster, and more explosive quicker using back squats than any. The back squat involves more musculature through a similarish range of motion compared to a front squat particularly if were comparing high bar back squats vs. Just that the single leg squat is just too good to pass up as a light exercise that cant offer benefits of its own. Dec 14, 2015 hey guys, what is your back squat to front squat ratio. The front squat and the back squat are two brothers. Eliminating back squats will be a bad idea for 99% of you.
173 1276 41 230 1114 796 50 1552 131 401 1485 1365 1189 312 60 1013 314 107 1297 910 619 304 1113 665 290 228 1138 321 171 748 1498 1396 113 1510 69 446 732 529 617 261 710 84 842 1100 1248